Brisingr summary 3

While searching through the cells in Helgrind Roran finds Katrina looking sick, and pale. As Roran looks for the key Eragon decides to search through the cells. In amazement he finds Sloan the father of Katrina with his eyes poked out. Eragon is troubled what to do, though eragon knows that killing Sloan quietly would be the merciful thing to do and the easiest way our of his conundrum, after all Sloan betrayed the village of Carvahall and killed Byrd. Eragon still cannot bring himself to cold-bloodedly murder anyone helpless. Eragon lies to Roran, and says that he had found Sloan's dead body. Roran in turn informs Katrina, and she closes he eyes and mourns.